Imogen (A Tale of Threshing Day)
Hello, all. Welcome back to the review of Threshing Day, a supplemental anthology for The Empyrean.
This past Wednesday, we began our review of Hive, Dan Abnett’s latest offering to Warhammer 40K. A point made in the content warning section of the overview is that profanity can serve a narrative function if used with deliberation and moderation. There is a single F-bomb dropped in the entire book, and it is delivered in the precise moment to maximize the impact of worldbuilding and character work in that scene.
Yarros writes like a child desperate to seem like a functional adult, so instead of doing what Abnett does, she vomits on the page in a grotesque parody of maturity. The opening of today’s story reads thusly:
Leaves crunch under my boots as I walk into the forest, having been dismissed after Bodhi’s less-than-rousing motivational speech that did nothing to improve my perpetually foul disposition. I sincerely hope some Navarrian asshole tries to exact revenge on me out here, because I’m in the mood to kill some people.
Fuck this day.
Fuck this kingdom.
Fuck everyone who put us in this godsforsaken torture chamber disguised as a war college.
I flinch. I can’t say that about Riorson. He made the only choice he could to save our lives after Navarre took those of our parents. He’s the only reason we’re still breathing, and I owe him my unflinching loyalty until one of us meets Malek.
Fuck General Sorrengail for making the deal.
Yeah. That’s better.
I would love nothing more than to sling Yarros’s vomit back into her face. In “Imogen”, she commits the same sin as “Garrick”, only in a more insultingly brazen manner. However, I aspire to be like Abnett, so I will instead say this:
“Imogen” is compelling evidence that neither Yarros and the editorial team at Red Tower care about the quality of this anthology. Why should they? When people are rewarded for treating the audience like drooling morons, they have no reason not to grow more and more insulting lazy.
Buckle into those Special Snowflake dragon saddles. It’s time to purge some initiates.
STATS
Title: “Imogen”
Series: The Empyrean (Supplemental Anthology)
Author(s): Rebecca Yarros
Genre: Fantasy (Epic)
First Printing: September 29th, 2026
Publisher: Red Tower Books
SPOILERS & DISCLAIMER
This post will provide heavy, unmarked spoilers for the entirety the Threshing Day anthology up through the end of the story being featured. Mild, unmarked stories for later stories may also be provided, while any heavy spoilers for later stories will be confined to clearly marked sections. I will do my best to keep the first paragraph of every section spoiler-free.
Heavy, unmarked spoilers will also be provided for all mainline books of The Empyrean (Fourth Wing, Iron Flame, and Onyx Storm) released prior to Threshing Day. I’m going to assume that you’ve read those previous reviews, but it won’t be necessary to understand this review, as I’ll be doing my best to recap or reference recurring issues or prior canon as it comes up.
For more information regarding the standards by which I’m going to be rating these stories, please see the post titled “Focus and Continuity (A Prelude to Threshing Day)”.
WHAT WE KNEW ABOUT IMOGEN BEFORE THRESHING DAY
Imogen is originally characterized as a tough-as-nails, no-nonsense individual. She hates Violet for being General Sorrengail’s daughter and wants revenge, but her loyalty to Xaden convinces her to back down and help Violet train. She gives Violet harsh yet practical advice about keeping secrets, only for us to be Told she reverses this position off-screen. Beyond that, she’s a rider with double Signets, one of which Yarros contrives uses for and the other of which seems to have been thrown in for a hollow moment of spectacle (and to cover up the Liam mistake).
This is another example of someone who started as a character but was reduced to a puppet for the plot. During the Iron Flame review, I was particularly annoyed by Imogen spilling the beans about the venin to Quinn just because Violet told the accessories. It was such a blatant violation of her character that, after the first read, I misremembered the interaction as Violet badgering Imogen into spilling the secret so as to not look as bad (and, given the the story is narrated by Violet, it would be far more in-character for the narrator to lie about Imogen doing this of her own free will).
The only other thing going on with Imogen is her attraction to Garrick. This was used to generate some tension when Violet misread the situation in Fourth Wing and got jealous because she thought Imogen was attracted to Xaden. Once the read resolved, this element faded into the background.
CONTENT
Imogen heads towards Glane, who marked her with a “claiming mark” (which must just be another name for the relic that forms during the official bonding we also saw in Chapter 16 of Fourth Wing, because that is the only way this story works) during Presentation. Garrick intercepts her. The pair discuss their romance, which boils down to, “Imogen wants to have sex with Garrick, but reasons that not being with him is protecting him … somehow.” This is interrupted by Glane channeling magic to Imogen. After Imogen grounds herself and gets the magic under control, she and Garrick bump into a Quinn.
Glance chooses this moment to reveal herself … and expose her genocidal hatred of Navarrians, trying to kill Quinn on the spot without any provocation, thereby putting Imogen’s life in danger. Imogen manifests her petrification Signet, turning a tree to stone to protect her, Garrick, and Quinn from Glane’s fire breath. The plot hole of Glane slipping past the scribes and rider leadership to bond with Imogen is called out, Yarros projects her inability to maintain continuity onto a non-character who doesn’t even have a name, and Imogen flies off with “a secret that would destroy Kaori’s faith in the Empyrean. But it restores mine.”
ANALYSIS
It truly speaks volumes of Yarros’s lack of respect for her audience. She makes the double Signets plot hole WIDER while putting in no additional effort to close it. The full assessment of that damage will come at the end, when we assess Glane’s character. Let’s get the odds and ends out of the way first.
Plot & Worldbuilding
The Early Bond
Glane gave Imogen a “claiming mark” during Presentation. We can conclude that this is just a new name for the standard relic all riders possess, for two reasons:
The bestowal is described in a manner that points back to Violet receiving her relic during the official ceremony in Chapter 16 of Fourth Wing.
Imogen does not receive an additional relic before she begins channeling magic in this story.
Again, I need to hold off on analyze this further until we assess Glane’s character. I just wanted to establish this bit up-front so we understand what we’re dealing with.
The Neophyte Master
Imogen is able to instantly handle magic because she is a third-generation rider who was taught how to do so by her mother and sister. Normally, I would file this sort of thing away as Yarros giving her protagonists “POWER for POWER’s sake”. However, by the rules of the magic system (soft though they are), this is actually an exceptional circumstance that makes complete sense.
Consider, if you will, Zaheer from The Legend of Korra. Almost immediately after gaining the ability to airbend, he’s so powerful and proficient that he’s able to escape from his cell (a cell that his bending can’t even directly affect) and defeat a whole team of White Lotus benders. This bizarre leap from non-bender to borderline master is justified by the two of the three pillars of bending: spirituality (i.e. embodying the spiritual worldview associated with the element being bent) and marital arts prowess. Before revealing his bending, Zaheer is established to have at least studied Air Nomad philosophy, with his spirituality unveiled as the season progresses). Supplemental materials (and, for that matter, the design of his cell) pointed to him being a skilled martial artist at the time of his arrest. He was, in short, already the ideal airbender. All he needed to be a great bender was the third pillar of bending (access to the power of the elements) and time to acclimate to it.
The same applies with Imogen. The magic of the Empyrean is:
Fueled by emotion
Commanded through willpower and focus
Regulated by mental discipline
While this does basically amount to, “Characters can do exactly as much magic as the plot requires,” it also means that someone can be trained to master the fundamentals of magic before having access to magic. All that’s needed to justify someone like Imogen is a coherent explanation for how she was able to be trained when someone as learned as Violet was not. The story provides that information: Imogen was trained by her family members. And, sure, we could argue that Violet also had access to rider family members who could have trained her, but it’s implied that Imogen’s family was invested in continuing a rider dynasty, while Violet was following her father’s footsteps into the Scribes. Couple this justification of Imogen’s training with the fact that her actual use of magic in this story is unrefined, demonstrating that she still needs to acclimate to the power itself, and this sudden transition from being POWERless to POWERful feels organic rather than forced for the sake of the plot.
Genocidal Dragons
So … there are dragons eager to butcher every human who did not side with Tyrrendor in the Apostacy.
Yeah. We’ll be coming back to that, both in dissecting the plot hole and the later discussions about dragons.
Double Signets
Quinn knew Imogen had two Signets from Day One, right? Because Quinn was climbing the tree that Imogen petrified. She would have noticed if it was made of stone before. So when Garrick does this:
“Good thing this tree was petrified,” Garrick says, knocking on the trunk.
Quinn should have immediately registered that magic shenanigans happened. Imogen using magic was the most obvious explanation (since Garrick’s official Signet would not have been secret, making Imogen the only logical source of the magical weirdness). By itself, that’s not a problem, but given that Imogen later went on-record with memory removal as her official Signet, Quinn should have put two and two together. (Once more, I will explain why this worsens the plot hole when we dissect Glane.)
Time Wasted
Once more, the dialogue that absorbs a huge chunk of the story has nothing to do with the binding with the dragon. This would be fine in a longer work. In stories this short, efficient storytelling matters. So far, only “Dain” has managed to soak up pages on an opening dialogue and then actually make it relevant to the ending.
Imogen
Imogen is a character again … but a badly written one.
Imogen’s entire identity is that she is a legacy rider who has been traumatized by the deaths of her mother and sister. The story Tells us that this has made her a very protective person. It’s the rationalization for why she refuses to be with Garrick.
I think this was done to justify her second (first?) Signet. Something we will get into at the end of this review series, when we do a spotlight analysis on memberberries, is that Yarros makes token efforts to explain many of the POV characters’ Signets. These range from hamfisted framing of POV character personalities and backstories to really dumb background details. Imogen is the former. To be fair, Yarros actually does something with it in the story, having Imogen’s Signet manifest in a moment she needs to protect someone, but it’s hard to ignore that this trait is built entirely around the Signet.
To show what I mean by this: why does Imogen think keeping her distance from Garrick protects him? She is happy to be friends with Quinn, so clearly, this can’t be a situation of, “Woe is me, I am cursed, everyone I love dies.” But if it’s not some broader defensive mechanism that pushes her to total isolation, then there’s no thorough line as to why Garrick specifically would be protected by her keeping her distance. Even Violet had more of a logical train of thought with protecting Andarna: the whole “riders are a threat to hatchlings” threat is nonsense if you think about it for more than two seconds, but at least it holds together for those two seconds because of the brutality of the Quadrant. Imogen’s thinking is so flawed that her reasoning falls apart the instant it is presented. Therefore, the idea that she is hardening her heart (petrifying it, if you would) to protect people doesn’t actually hold weight. She’s just holding Garrick at arm’s length because Yarros wants angst.
Also, this idea that Imogen wants to protect people further falls flat when you consider that, two years later in Iron Flame, she involves Quinn in the activities of the rebel children, thereby endangering Quinn. The only way that this supposed core trait is not contradicted by that decision is if my theory about Violet harassing her into it is indeed correct. At least then, whatever pressure (or abuse) Violet applied to help make herself look less bad by comparison would function as a change in circumstances to prompt the shift in Imogen’s character.
Romance
I didn’t comment on this with “Garrick” but since we now have both sides of it, it is worth commenting upon.
Garrick longs for the girl he loved since he was a child. She is an amazing woman in his eyes. He misses her and hates that he cannot be there for her. This is an emotional relationship for him.
Imogen looks at Garrick, yearns for him sexually, and is angry at him for not visiting her despite fully understanding the rational reasons why he could not.
Wow. Yarros writes such variety into her romances, doesn't she?
Now, Imogen being mad at Garrick makes far more sense that Violet being mad at Xaden. Imogen is just dealing with hurt feelings, and she is expressing that she is hurt. She is not equating sex with a security clearance and threatening the entire rebellion while grasping at excuses to be angry.
On the flip side of this, though … since Yarros asserts that these stories are about expressing what women “deserve” … Yarros’s vision of romance is that men are emotionally devoted, while woman sexually objectify men.
How virtuous.
Speaking of virtue ..
Quinn
“Oh, I can tell.” Quinn glowers at him. “I’m so glad I’m into girls. You men are all drama.”
HEY! DEAR READER!
DID YOU KNOW YARROS IS AN ALLY?
I KNOW IT IS EASY TO FORGET! I KNOW SHE HAS GONE A HERETICAL AMOUNT OF TIME WITHOUT SHINING THE SIGNAL OF HER VIRTUE!
BUT DON’T WORRY - THE RAINBOW AQUILLA HAS BEEN FLASHED! YOU CAN DISENGAGE THOSE BOLTERS NOW! THE EMPEROR’S MERCY SHALL NOT BE REQUIRED HERE!
…
Seriously, would it have been so hard to let Quinn just be a character defined by choosing to be Imogen’s friend despite Imogen being a rebel child? What narrative purpose is served by wasting precious time to remind us all of her sexuality (which, given her overwrought death scene in Onyx Storm, should now be firmly cemented in everyone’s minds) while doing nothing else for her character work?
Moments like this are precisely why virtue signals, especially those built around tokenized characters, offend me. If an author is going to slap the audience about the face with a message (and, yes, in our contemporary landscape where identity politics mandate “inclusion”, forced diversity is indeed serving a message), the very least that author can do is commit to said message and put in a genuine effort. The fact authors like Yarros insist on calling attention to their own virtue while not putting in the effort to actually earn that virtue is insulting lazy.
You know what someone who genuinely cared about diversity would have done here? Made this whole story about Quinn and Imogen’s friendship and how bonding to Glane threatens to unbalance everything. Don’t bring up Quinn’s sexuality at all, and don’t make the first half of this story about Imogen and Garrick’s romance. Make the dialogue between Imogen and Quinn and delve deep into how Imogen is this the hard-hearted and bitter young woman hoping to strike back at Navarre, only to find herself with cracks in her armor because of this friendly and accepting person who’s come into her life. Explore Imogen’s inner conflict about being friends with the enemy. Then, have Glane show up and try to Quinn. Imogen would be need to choose between serving hers and Glane’s mutual agenda or protecting this innocent soul who has been nothing but kind to her.
Having Quinn be a background character who just shows up to remind us of her sexuality is the dehumanizing. It shows that Yarros wants to be seen Including people without actually Including them in a way that would affect the story or characters she truly cares about.
Then again, the overall writing is devoid of any sort of integrity, so perhaps asking Yarros to actually humanize the people she tokenizes is just too tall of an order.
Speaking of writing devoid of integrity …
Glane
Quick note before we start: “Imogen” establishes that Glane is not this dragon’s real name. However, we have not been given another name to work with. Glane’s true name also has no bearing on the quality of the writing. (Similar logic applies to Chradh, too, though his story didn’t put focus on him using a false name.)
Finally, Another Dragon Character
Glane was previously riden by Imogen’s grandmother. Odds are pretty good that there were no other riders in between. Aside from the fact Imogen’s grandmother was alive as recently as 15 years prior to the events of “Imgoen” (since Imogen is 20 now, and she first met Glane when she was “five”), Glane is extremely invested in Imogen’s family, to the point that she views the deaths of Imogen’s mother and sister as crimes to be avenged upon every Navarrian she can reach.
This devotion makes Glane the first dragon among the rebel children with a clear motivation to bond with a rebel child. She is invested in Imogen because, in a sense, Imogen is family to her.
Glane is also a bloodthirsty dragon. She is eager to tell Imogen about her kill count.
This bloodthirst is a problem. We are Shown that Glane is eager to kill Navarrians. She goes after Quinn, despite knowing Quinn is Imogen’s friend and despite Imogen being close enough to be harmed by the attempt, for no other reason than the fact that Quinn is a Navarrian and is guilty by association for the deaths of Imogen’s mother and sister. Has she been going around murdering Navarrians for the past four years? If so, why has she faced no consequences? If not, why does she lash out at Quinn specifically (especially since, again, Imogen is close enough to be harmed)?
The Plot Hole Widens, and the Lie Gets Worse
With Imogen and Glane, Yarros had the same problem that she had with Garrick and Chradh. She needed to justify how no one picked up on the fact that these dragons are bonding with rebel children who are descendants on past riders, and she already pulled the false heritage trick with Xaden and Sgaeyl. How, then, does she resolve this?
By going out of her way to make it impossible for Glane to get away with this, then projecting her sins onto non-character.
All of the issues that previously surfaced in “Garrick” when Chradh lied about his identity also apply here with Glane. I won’t rehash those recurring issues here. We’re just going to focus on all the new problems that make Glane’s deception uniquely incompatible with what Yarros has written.
A few deep breaths first.
…
…
…
First, we are explictly told, in this very story, that Imogen’s grandmother was riding Glane as recently as 15 years ago. This means the family connection is in living memory for humans. Other riders should recognize her, to say nothing of the dragons within the Empyrean who are aligned with the rider leadership. Glane is also physically distinct enough that Imogen recognizes her despite apparently not having seen this specific dragon for those 15 years. (If it has been less time, it worsens this “living memory” problem by making Glane’s recent service even more recent.) Couple this with the fact Imogen is a third-generation rider whose mother and sister (and their dragons, of course) sided with Tyrrendor in the Apostacy. At least with Chradh, we could maybe headcanon that maybe his connection to Garrick’s ancestors was several generations ago and that maybe he hasn’t taken a rider for centuries, so human beings would have to go out of their way to connect the dots. Here, every human being in the rider leadership and Scribes would need to be an enormous dumbass to miss this. Frankly, given that combinations of color and tail weapon are recorded, merely the fact that Imogen would bond to a dragon with similar traits to her grandmother’s should lead these highly paranoid antagonists to investigate. (Remember, these people executed a rider for using the official document request system to ask about a report he couldn’t have known was classified.) And if the answer to the combination thing is that dragons can change their tail weapons in a short period of time, then (A) people wouldn’t be using tail weapons as an identifier in official records, and (B) that doesn’t overrule the fact that Glane is still apparently a very recognizable dragon that Imogen knows on sight despite not having seen her for many years.
Second, Glane marked Imogen during Presentation. Even if Imogen did not visibly react to this explicitly painful process, how did no other dragons notice this? None of them found it suspicious that this dragon is jumping the gun? None of them asked questions?
Third, there’s Glane’s genocidal hatred of Navarrians. She tries to slaughter Quinn while psychically screeching about Quinn being associated with the people who killed the daughter and granddaughter of her last rider. This explosive hatred isn’t provoked, which implies she is just that ready to murder Navarrians. Are no other dragons aware of this? Do they not have questions when this psychopathic loose cannon bonds with a rebel child? Does Quinn's dragon Cruth not care that this violent bigot went after his rider? Does Melgren the Omniscient not sense this altercation (iff we are meant to think the fight with Alic would get Melgren’s attention, this should, too) and see Imogen shouting about Quinn not being guilty, a fact which by itself would out that this killing was motivated by something other than the usual draconic belligerence even if Cruth didn’t pick up on the psychic screeching?
Fourth, the petrification Signet has now been confirmed to be Imogen’s first Signet. Why was memory removal the one officially registered? Why would Imogen hide the petrification Signet from Carr? When did the memory removal Signet even manifest? Given that memory removal is a classified Signet (and, thus, one that draws attention to Imogen) and is one that does not leave external evidence (since, you know, that is the point of erasing memories), why would Imogen not keep the memory removal secret and let petrification be the official one? Especially since, you know, Quinn should already know about the petrification Signet. Given that Imogen is big on keeping secrets (until Yarros needs her not to be so that Violet looks less irresponsible), why would she not protect the secret of the double Signets by making sure the Signet she goes public about is the one Quinn already knows of? (And, no, erasing Quinn’s memory is not an adequate explanation. With how Imogen’s power has been framed, she can only do short-term memories, wiping out what a person just witnessed. So unless the memory erasure manifests within minutes of this incident, removing Quinn’s memory of this event should not be possible. And even if it is possible, or even if the Signet manifests right away, we have been given no indication that Imogen can cherry-pick details, so we’d be left with a situation where Quinn can’t remember her own Threshing. The rider leadership - you know, the people who execute riders for using official channels to request documents they have no reason to believe are classified - would investigate something like that.)
…
…
…
Now that I am done gasping for breath, how does Yarros resolve this?
“I am recorded as Glane to all.” She tilts her head down at me, making me feel like I’m five all over again. “Including you.”
Saying that Glane is not this dragon’s true name does not close the plot hole.
If “all” doesn’t include dragons, the dragons allied with the rider leadership know who Glane is, will know she is lying about her name, and could simply expose her to the rider leadership. They have the means and motivation to expose Glane.
If “all” does include the dragons, implying that all other dragons are fooled by this, then we are expected to believe that dragons are incapable of telling each other apart, yet a human can identify dragons from memory.
How the hell did she pull that off? Kaori’s predecessor must have kept shitty records.
Lampshading a plot hole is not a solution. Blaming Kaori’s predecessor also does not work. Not only is this individual not a character with the necessary depth to support the providing of false information to the audience, but “Trial by Fire” made it explicit that Dragonkind professors are explicitly instructed to keep these records. At best, Yarros is tearing a character down (blaming Kaori’s predecessor) rather than building characters up (Glane successfully gets this lie past everyone by being clever). This anthology certainly has a track record of that, given all the Red Shirts branded as idiots or thugs so the POVs look better by comparison. At worst, Yarros has gone out of her way to make it less likely for a character to make the mistake she claims took place here. (And that’s before we consider the fact that, given Yarros’s track record for projecting deception onto non-characters, projecting her own evident inability to keep track of her own lore would be very on-brand.)
This is so bizarre. Yarros has done pretty much everything she could to take an already existing plot hole and make it worse, then just expected everyone to ignore that while she handwaved away the consequences. It’s as if she gets some sick thrill out of hurling her feces at her readers.
RATING: 1/10
This story is the embodiment of Yarros’s self-sabotaging efforts to cover her own ass. Much like the Liam error this kicked off this chain of retcons to begin with, doing nothing to explain how the rebel children’s dragons snuck past the scribes and rider leadership would have been the better option. In her efforts to cover up her mistakes, Yarros only succeeds in demonstrating that she doesn’t think things through and has no idea what she is doing.
You want to know how easy it would be to fix this?
Have Glane mutilate herself.
Glane is clearly unhinged. She is driven to madness by grief and willing to visit violence on everyone and everyone. She wants to hide her identity, and she is a visually distinct dragon. And so, in her blind pursuit of her revenge, she resorts to extreme measures to make herself unrecognizable. She goes into the wilderness for years while she waits for Imogen to come to Basgiath. She gnaws off the tip of her own tail, files her horns into a slightly different shape, gives up on grooming and puts herself in situations that accelerate the weathering of her scales. Maybe she even finds out Sgaeyl is on the side of the rebel children and gets Sgaeyl to maul her in a way that looks bad without doing permanent damage. Then, this half-mad, obsessive dragon comes for Imogen.
The humans look at this obviously feral dragon, peruse their records, and confirm that they have absolutely no records of her. And even if the dragons do recognize her (because we have no reason to believe that the Empyrean is such a large community that a new dragon would not be noticed), Glane’s obvious insanity makes her breaking the rules by bonding with Imogen a lot less suspicious. The rider leadership would shrug and say, “I guess this one has an extra Signet. Keep an eye on her.” Imogen could then be one of the double Signet riders who Xaden implied that Kaori already knows about.
Is this perfect? Not at all. It still is a massive stretch in terms of the hyper-paranoid rider leadership not intervening. Still, what I just suggested turns a lie into a character-based deception by building up the character in question. It’s better than Yarros’s seemingly inevitable fallback of acknowledging problems as an alternative to solving them and projecting her own behavior onto entities who aren’t even characters.
OH YEAH, RHIANNON’S IN THIS SERIES
Yarros has treated Violet’s original group of accessories with every-increasing levels of disinterest as the mainline series progressed, taking them from a validating background chorus in Fourth Wing and sweeping them ever and ever further into narrative irrelevance with each passing book. Even Ridoc, who was restored as a character in Onyx Storm, really only gets built up again so that he can have that one scene with Violet at the two-thirds mark before retreating into the background. It should therefore come as no surprise that “Rhiannon”, the story about a Best Friend archetype quickly made redundant by Violet’s friendship with the rebel children, is one of the more bland and pointless stories in this anthology. It doesn’t damage the wider narrative, which is a point in its favor, but it is still incredibly pointless. You can tell Yarros was struggling to actually write 13 stories for this book.
That’s coming November 29th. In the interim, if you’re looking for Fantasy fiction that doesn’t spit on your intelligence, my free serial Moral Support is ongoing. It’s a Dark Fantasy story where motorbike-riding Persian alchemists face off against medieval Balkan soldiers in a haunted forest. Chapter 1 through Chapter 5 Part 2 are now available.
Thank you all for stopping by. Please remember to subscribe and share if you enjoyed what you read here. Take care, everyone, and have a good week.
