Bodhi (A Tale of Threshing Day)
Hello, all, and Happy Shichi-Go-San. Welcome back to the review of Threshing Day, a supplemental anthology for The Empyrean.
Among the non-characters of The Empyrean, Bodhi is among the most bland. He is Xaden’s cousin. That’s pretty much it.
Today’s story Tells us a lot about him … and it all amounts to him just being Xaden’s cousin. This is another story of filler. It’s more streamlined filler than what we got with, say, “Brennan”, but filler nonetheless. Despite Bodhi being the POV, most of what I have to say about this story has nothing to do with him specifically.
Buckle into those Special Snowflake dragon saddles. It’s time to purge some initiates.
STATS
Title: “Bodhi”
Series: The Empyrean (Supplemental Anthology)
Author(s): Rebecca Yarros
Genre: Fantasy (Epic)
First Printing: September 29th, 2026
Publisher: Red Tower Books
SPOILERS & DISCLAIMER
This post will provide heavy, unmarked spoilers for the entirety the Threshing Day anthology up through the end of the story being featured. Mild, unmarked stories for later stories may also be provided, while any heavy spoilers for later stories will be confined to clearly marked sections. I will do my best to keep the first paragraph of every section spoiler-free.
Heavy, unmarked spoilers will also be provided for all mainline books of The Empyrean (Fourth Wing, Iron Flame, and Onyx Storm) released prior to Threshing Day. I’m going to assume that you’ve read those previous reviews, but it won’t be necessary to understand this review, as I’ll be doing my best to recap or reference recurring issues or prior canon as it comes up.
For more information regarding the standards by which I’m going to be rating these stories, please see the post titled “Focus and Continuity (A Prelude to Threshing Day)”.
WHAT WE KNEW ABOUT BODHI BEFORE THRESHING DAY
Bodhi has been a less interesting version of Garrick. The only thing that separates him from Garrick is the fact that he is Xaden’s cousin and has a different Signet, one that is potentially quite POWERful but that Yarros seemingly avoids utilizing. In fact, if you were to name any scene that features Bodhi or Garrick where Signets or familial relations are not a factor, I would struggle to remember which one was actually involved in that scene.
Onyx Storm added some quirks to Bodhi. First, Yarros gave very mixed messaging on him having a second Signet. Bodhi claims he doesn’t have one, and Yarros has asserted in interviews that he doesn’t, but as I covered in the Onyx Storm review, the way he words his claim of having no Signet only really makes sense if the idea is that he’s trying to subtly tell Violet that he has one. The second quirk is that Bodhi is the next in line to take over Xaden’s noble title if anything happens to Xaden. This was introduced right before the climax of the book and then narratively shelved by Xaden marrying Violet in that ending Yarros couldn’t be bothered to actually write.
CONTENT
During his Threshing, Bodhi encounters Xaden, who reveals that Sgaeyl has already arranged a dragon for him (Cuir) and then escorts Bodhi across the valley to Cuir’s position. Along the way, they discuss Xaden’s love life and how the Quadrant has changed Xaden and how Bodhi is tired of the conflict. This abruptly morphs into Bodhi desiring agency and being suicidal, with him rushing over to a random blue dragon just to see if he will bond with it. Cuir saves him from this stupidity and tells Bodhi that he can either submit to being Cuir’s rider or fall to his death.
ANALYSIS
Wow. More filler. How delightful.
Honestly, the most substantive part of this story was the discussion of Xaden’s love life. It’s just a memberberry, but at least it’s a (mostly) functional memberberry. That’s better than nothing.
The rest of this story? It’s nothing. It’s actually worse than nothing. In trying to find something, anything, to stuff the page count of this book, Yarros made yet more unforced errors.
Plot & Worldbuilding
The only point of note here is that Xaden has not yet told Bodhi about the smuggling operation. He drops hints that he’s going to tell Bodhi something important if Bodhi survives Threshing and bonds to a dragon, and he makes a reference to needing to go somewhere with Garrick. This is a rare moment where Yarros actually manages to add detail to the world without making things worse. Knowing that Xaden doesn’t share secrets with the rebel children until they are riders (and, thus, can actively contribute to the smuggling operation) provides clarity without contradicting anything.
There is also something to be said about Sgaeyl arranging for Cuir to be Bodhi’s rider. It provides a justification for why Cuir would choose Bodhi by leaning on Sgaeyl’s characterization, rather than Cuir’s. Sgaeyl supports this rebellion (for reasons that still have not been explored, but nevertheless, she does) and demonstrated with Xaden that she is willing to flout conventions for choosing riders in the name of that goal. Her arranging dragons for rebel children makes sense for her.
Xaden
No, this is not Xaden’s story, but there’s a lot more to be said about him than Bodhi.
Love Life
Xaden’s relationship with Cat is something that was previously brought up in “Garrick” and rehashed here. It’s not particularly deep. Xaden was dreading the betrothal during his own Threshing because he hated Cat, and a year later, he still hates spending time with her. To him, this betrothal has always been about a political alliance.
I am mixed about this. I do like that Yarros is reviving this in a context where Violet is not present. Much like with Xaden himself, this gives the relationship life beyond being an easily overcome jealousy conflict for Violet. The problem is that, by making it clear that Xaden has always hated Cat, making it clear that he is going along with it purely for politics, and then setting things up in “Bodhi” for him to break off the engagement, Yarros enflames issues that had been dormant since Iron Flame.
If this betrothal was always about politics for Xaden, why did he break it off? This runs counter to the characterization of him doing whatever was necessary to continue his father’s war. If an alternative alliance had presented himself, or if the breakup had happened because of him meeting Violet and discovering he valued love over duty, or if he had thought he loved Cat but been disillusioned after the betrothal kicked into gear, fine. Those could be justified by character. For him to go into this for duty despite dreading it, only to break things off because he wasn’t enjoying himself, is just a betrayal of his values.
If it was always this bad, and if Xaden broke things off with Cat before meeting Violet, why did Cat think she had a shot of winning Xaden back by undermining Violet? We can argue that maybe she was just delusional, but given how quickly she gets over it and moves on in Onyx Storm, she seems a bit too level-headed and mature to be this blind.
Why did Xaden have sex with Cat if it was just about politics and if he hated her this much? Sex in the marriage to sustain the political alliance and produce heirs is duty. Sex beforehand makes substantially less sense. It would also exacerbates the issue of Cat thinking she had a hold on him, which is something he clearly doesn’t want. I get that there are men who will take sex where they will get it, but Xaden has been characterized throughout the mainline books as someone who does not simply go for easy sex. Remember, in Fourth Wing, he keeps Violet at an arm’s length despite their sexual attraction, and when his offer for casual sex where Violet respects his autonomy is rebuffed, he drops the matter, forcing Violet to chase him. It is therefore a hard sell that he’d have sex for any purposes other than duty when the relationship is someone he despises.
Did he change?
Bodhi makes a big deal during the conversation about the Quadrant making Xaden more callous and prone to using lethal force. I’m going to have to call bullshit on that.
Here’s the problem. The earliest point in Xaden’s timeline that we’ve seen was “Xaden”. Just a few months into his life in the Quadrant, before he ever gets a dragon, Xaden is already the man he’d be a year later in this story. He is also this same man the year after that, for the start of the mainline series. It is not impossible that Xaden could have been a softer person a few months earlier, but Yarros chose not to show us that softer time. She chose to show us a Xaden who is already Xaden.
This isn’t just informed characterization. It’s informed characterization where the only evidence that might have substantiated it presents the opposite information. Yarros has actively disproven this idea.
Bodhi
Bodhi is Xaden’s current successor, whose life is geared around supporting Xaden.
So we are Told.
I really have no idea what Yarros was going for here. Maybe the goal was to retread “Dain”: have Bodhi be a burdened by expectations and then try to be his own man. His suicidal charge towards a random blue dragon does imply a desire for agency, and Cuir psychoanalyzes him having a desire for agency when he snatches Bodhi away from certain death. There are two reasons this doesn’t work, though:
Cuir gives Bodhi an ultimatum: to submit and be Cuir’s rider, or die. There is an argument to be made about this thematically in the sense of a broaden discussion of free will, but on the scale in which agency is actually being applied, the choice between submission and death is not actually a choice. (I will expand upon this idea in much greater detail when we get to “Sawyer”.) If agency was the theme Yarros was playing with, her message here is, “Lol no, Xaden’s cousin gets no choice in the matter.” At least with Dain, he didn’t know the right answer, and becoming a rider was the reward. Death wasn’t being used to force compliance.
The discussion beforehand is about Xaden’s agency, not Bodhi’s, so this doesn’t come across like an arc.
Bottom line … Bodhi is not a character in his own POV story. He is a sock puppet, used to drive Xaden’s story before being shoved onto Cuir’s claw.
Cuir
Much like Cath, Cuir is not a character. There is nothing to be gleaned from a dragon saying, “Commit to the established canon or die.”
RATING: 5/10
“Bodhi” is marginally better than “Brennan”. At least the time wasted is applied to advance someone’s story, even if it isn’t the titular character’s. The plot holes it opens with Xaden and Cat are also isolated; it’s not like they really damage much about the wider siders.
At the end of the day, though, this story is another instance of pointless filler. Yarros didn’t have an actual story to tell here. compared to the previous few POVs, I doubt she even has any interest in Bodhi at all.
DOES YARROS KNOW HOW TO DO ANYTHING BUT PROJECT?
“Imogen”, the next story in Threshing Day, enrages me even more than “Garrick”. In it, Yarros once more shines a spotlight on a plot hole without correcting, once again heaps blame for her own dishonest writing onto non-characters. This time, she does manage to justify the lie by attaching it to an actual character … but then, for that lie to succeed, she makes non-characters into idiots incapable of maintaining the most basic continuity of information. It is a textbook example of Yarros going out of her way to make her story worse to avoid owning up to her own mistakes.
That’s coming November 22nd. In the interim, if you’re looking for more Romantasy, you can find my free web serial, A Chime for These Hallowed Bones. It’s an Enemies to Lovers story that’s Alchemized meets Fourth Wing, featuring necromancers in a Desi-influenced setting. Chapters 1 through Chapter 12 are currently available.
Thank you all for stopping by. Please remember to subscribe and share if you enjoyed what you read here. Take care, everyone, and have a good week.
